Advertisement

Pain and women's satisfaction with the experience of childbirth: A systematic review

      Abstract

      Objective: To summarize what is known about satisfaction with childbirth, with particular attention to the roles of pain and pain relief. Study Design: A systematic review of 137 reports of factors influencing women's evaluations of their childbirth experiences. The reports included descriptive studies, randomized controlled trials, and systematic reviews of intrapartum interventions. Results were summarized qualitatively. Results: Four factors—personal expectations, the amount of support from caregivers, the quality of the caregiver-patient relationship, and involvement in decision making—appear to be so important that they override the influences of age, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, childbirth preparation, the physical birth environment, pain, immobility, medical interventions, and continuity of care, when women evaluate their childbirth experiences. Conclusion: The influences of pain, pain relief, and intrapartum medical interventions on subsequent satisfaction are neither as obvious, as direct, nor as powerful as the influences of the attitudes and behaviors of the caregivers. (Am J Obstet Gynecol 2002;186:S160-72.)

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Brown S
        • Lumley J.
        The 1993 survey of recent mothers: issues in survey design, analysis and influencing policy.
        Int J Qual Health Care. 1997; 9: 264-275
        • Brown S
        • Lumley J.
        Changing childbirth: lessons from an Australian survey of 1336 women.
        Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1998; 105: 143-155
        • Fitzpatrick R.
        Surveys of patient satisfaction: I. Important general considerations.
        Br Med J. 1991; 302: 887-889
        • Ross A.
        Maternal satisfaction with labour analgesia.
        Baillieres Clin Obstet Gynaecol. 1998; 12: 498-513
        • Bramadat IJ
        • Driedger M.
        Satisfaction with childbirth: theories and methods of measurement.
        Birth. 1993; 20: 22-29
        • Hall JA
        • Dornan MC.
        Meta-analysis of satisfaction with medical care: Description of research domain and analysis of overall satisfaction levels.
        Soc Sci Med. 1988; 27: 637-644
        • Wensing M
        • Grol R
        • Smits A.
        Quality judgements by patients on general practice care: a literature analysis.
        Soc Sci Med. 1994; 38: 45-53
      1. Cochrane Library. Update Software, Oxford2000 ([computer program] Issue 4)
        • Sackett D.
        “Bias in analytic research.”.
        J Chronic Dis. 1979; 32: 51-63
        • Forchuk C
        • Roberts J.
        “How to critique qualitative research articles.”.
        Can J Nurs Res. 1993; 25: 47-56
      2. Hodnett E. Pain and women's satisfaction with the experience of childbirth: a systematic review. Available at http://www.maternitywise.org/prof/pain/

        • Climie CR
        • Cope TI
        • Stevens LH
        • Lancaster P
        • Parkinson RS
        • Sutherland R
        • et al.
        Consumer satisfaction in the labour ward.
        Med J Aust. 1973; 2: 1081-1084
        • Shields D.
        Nursing care in labor and patient satisfaction: a descriptive study.
        J Adv Nurs. 1978; 3: 535-550
        • Cartright A.
        The dignity of labour? A study of childbearing and induction.
        Tavistock, London1979
        • Butani P
        • Hodnett E.
        Mothers' perceptions of their labor experiences.
        Matern Child Nurs J. 1980; 9: 73-82
        • Kirke PN.
        Mothers' views of obstetric care.
        Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1980; 87: 1029-1033
        • Kirke PN.
        Mothers'views of care in labour.
        Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1980; 87: 1034-1038
        • Morgan BM
        • Bulpitt CJ
        • Lewis PJ.
        Analgesia and satisfaction in childbirth (The Queen Charlotte's 1000 Mother Survey).
        Lancet. 1982; 9: 808-811
        • Sullivan DA
        • Beeman R.
        Satisfaction with maternity care: a matter of communication and choice.
        Med Care. 1982; 20: 321-330
        • Nelson MK.
        Working-class women, middle-class women, and models of childbirth.
        Social Problems. 1983; 30: 284-297
        • Jacoby A.
        Women's preferences for and satisfaction with current procedures in childbirth-findings from a national study.
        Midwifery. 1987; 3: 117-124
        • Brown S
        • Lumley J.
        Satisfaction with care in labor and birth: a survey of 790 Australian women.
        Birth. 1989; 21: 4-13
        • Drew NC
        • Salmon P
        • Webb L.
        Mothers', midwives' and obstetricians' views on the features of obstetric care which influence satisfaction with childbirth.
        Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1989; 96: 1084-1088
        • Séguin L
        • Therrien R
        • Champagne
        • Larouch D.
        The components of women's satisfaction with maternity care.
        Birth. 1989; 16: 109-113
        • Green JM
        • Coupland VA
        • Kitzinger JV.
        Expectations, experiences, and psychological outcomes of childbirth: a prospective study of 825 women.
        Birth. 1990; 17: 15-24
        • Green JM.
        Expectations and experiences of pain in labor: findings from a large prospective study.
        Birth. 1993; 20: 65-72
        • Salmon R
        • Miller R.
        Women's anticipation and experience of childbirth: the independence of fulfilment, unpleasantness and pain.
        Br J Med Psychol. 1990; 63: 255-259
        • Simkin P.
        Just another day in a woman's life? Women's long-term perceptions of their first birth experience. Part I.
        Birth. 1991; 18: 203-210
        • Simkin P.
        Just another day in a woman's life? Part II: Nature and consistency of women's long-term memories of their first birth experiences.
        Birth. 1992; 19: 64-81
        • Salmon P
        • Drew NC.
        Multidimensional assessment of women's experience of childbirth: relationships to obstetric procedures, antenatal preparation and obstetric history.
        J Psychosom Res. 1992; 36: 317-327
        • Slade P
        • MacPherson SA
        • Hume A
        • Maresh M.
        Expectations, experiences and satisfaction with labour.
        J Clin Psychol. 1993; 32: 469-483
        • Ranta P
        • Spalding M
        • Kangas-Saarela T
        • Jokela R
        • Hollmen A
        • Jouppila P
        • et al.
        Maternal expectations and experiences of labour pain: opinions of 1091 Finnish parturients.
        Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 1995; 39: 60-66
        • Waldenstrom U
        • Borg I
        • Ollson B
        • Skold M
        • Wall S.
        The childbirth experience: a study of 295 new mothers.
        Birth. 1996; 23: 144-153
        • Knapp L.
        Childbirth satisfaction: the effects of internality and perceived control.
        J Perinat Educ. 1996; 5: 7-15
        • Geary M
        • Fanagan M
        • Boylan P.
        Maternal satisfaction with management in labour and preferences for mode of delivery.
        J Perinat Med. 1997; 25: 433-439
        • Hung CH
        • Hsu YY
        • Lee SF.
        Couples' satisfaction with health care service during labor and delivery.
        Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 1997; 13: 255-262
        • McCrea BH.
        Satisfaction in childbirth and perceptions of personal control in pain relief during labour.
        J Adv Nurs. 1999; 29: 877-884
        • Fowles ER.
        Labor concerns of women two months after delivery.
        Birth. 1998; 25: 235-240
        • Campero L
        • Garcia C
        • Diaz C
        • Ortiz O
        • Reynoso S
        • Langer A
        Alone, I wouldn't have known what to do: a qualitative study on social support during labour and delivery in Mexico.
        Soc Sci Med. 1998; 47: 395-403
        • Small R
        • Rice PL
        • Yelland J
        • Lumley J.
        Mothers in a new country: the role of culture and communication in Vietnamese, Turkish and Filippino women's experiences of giving birth in Australia.
        Women Health. 1999; 28: 77-101
        • Waldenstrom U.
        Experience of labor and birth in 1111 women.
        J Psychosom Res. 1999; 5: 471-482
        • Lavender T
        • Walkinshaw SA
        • Walton I.
        A prospective study of women's views of factors contributing to a positive birth experience.
        Midwifery. 1999; 15: 40-46
        • Windridge KC
        • Berryman JC.
        Women's experiences of giving birth after 35.
        Birth. 1999; 26: 16-23
        • Kabakian-Khasholian T
        • Campbell O
        • Shediac-Rizkallah M
        • Ghorayeb F.
        Women's experiences of maternity care: satisfaction or passivity?.
        Soc Sci Med. 2000; 51: 103-113
        • Killien MG
        • Shy K.
        A randomized trial of electronic fetal monitoring in preterm labor: mother's views.
        Birth. 1989; 16: 7-12
        • Turnbull D
        • Holmes A
        • Shields N
        • Cheyne H
        • Twaddle S
        • Gilmour WH
        • et al.
        Randomised controlled trial of efficacy of midwife-managed care.
        Lancet. 1996; 348: 213-218
        • Shields N
        • Turnbull D
        • Reid M
        • Holmes A
        • McGinley M
        • Smith LN.
        Satisfaction with midwife-managed care in different time periods: a randomised controlled trial of 1299 women.
        Midwifery. 1998; 14: 85-91
        • Hodnett ED
        • Hannah ME
        • Weston JA
        • Ohlsson A
        • Myhr TL
        • Wang EE
        • et al.
        Women's evaluations of induction of labor versus expectant management for prelabor rupture of the membranes at term.
        in: Birth. 24. 1997: 214-220
        • Blanch G
        • Lavender T
        • Walkinshaw S
        • Alfirevic Z.
        Dysfunctional labour: a randomised trial.
        Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1998; 105: 117-120
        • McNiven PS
        • Williams JI
        • Hodnett ED
        • Kaufman K
        • Hannah ME.
        An early labor assessment program: a randomized controlled trial.
        Birth. 1998; 25: 5-10
        • Lavender T
        • Wallymahmed A
        • Walkinshaw S.
        Managing labor using partograms with different action lines: a prospective study of women's views.
        Birth. 1999; 26: 89-96
        • Fraser WD
        • Turcot L
        • Krauss I
        • Brisson-Carrol G.
        Amniotomy for shortening spontaneous labour. The Cochrane Library.
        Update Software, Oxford2000 ([software program] Issue 4)
        • Gupta JK
        • Nikodem VC.
        Woman's position during second stage of labour. The Cochrane Library.
        Update Software, Oxford2000 ([software program] Issue 4)
        • Hodnett ED.
        Caregiver support for women during childbirth. The Cochrane Library.
        Update Software, Oxford2000 ([software program] Issue 4)
        • Hodnett ED.
        Home-like versus conventional institutional settings for birth. The Cochrane Library.
        Update Software, Oxford2000 ([software program] Issue 4)
        • Hodnett ED.
        Continuity of caregivers for care during pregnancy and childbirth. The Cochrane Library.
        Update Software, Oxford2000 ([software program] Issue 4)
        • Waldenstrom U
        • Brown S
        • McLachlan H
        • Forster D
        • Brennecke S.
        Does team midwife care increase satisfaction with antenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care? A randomized controlled trial.
        Birth. 2000; 27: 156-167
        • Harrison RF
        • Woods T
        • Shore M
        • Mathews G
        • Unwin A.
        Pain relief in labour using transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS). A TENS/TENS placebo controlled study in two parity groups.
        Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1986; 93: 739-746
        • Frank M
        • McAteer EJ
        • Cattermole R
        • Loughnan B
        • Stafford LB
        • Hitchcock AM.
        Nalbuphine for obstetric analgesia: a comparison of nalbuphine with pethidine for pain relief in labour when administered by patient-controlled analgesia (PCA).
        Anaesthesia. 1987; 42: 697-703
        • Gambling DR
        • Yu P
        • McMorland GH
        • Palmer L.
        A comparative study of patient controlled epidural analgesia (PCEA) and continuous infusion epidural analgesia (CIEA) during labour.
        Can J Anaesth. 1988; 35: 249-254
        • Smedstad KG
        • Morison DH.
        A comparative study of continuous and intermittent epidural analgesia for labour and delivery.
        Can J Anaesth. 1988; 35: 234-241
        • Gambling DR
        • McMorland GH
        • Yu P
        • Laszlo C.
        Comparison of patient-controlled epidural analgesia and conventional intermittent “top-up” injections during labor.
        Anesth Analg. 1990; 70: 256-261
        • Sinatra RS
        • Goldstein R
        • Sevarino FB.
        The clinical effectiveness of epidural bupivicaine, bupivacaine with lidocaine, and bupivacaine with fentanyl for labor analgesia.
        J Clin Anesth. 1991; 3: 219-224
        • Fontenot RJ
        • Price RL
        • Henry A
        • Reisner LS
        • Weinger MB.
        Double-blind evaluation of patient-controlled epidural analgsia during labor.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 1993; 2: 73-77
        • Russell R
        • Groves P
        • Reynold F.
        Is opioid loading necessary before opioid/local anaesthetic epidural infusions? A randomized double-blind study in labour.
        Int J Obstet Anesth. 1993; 2: 78-84
        • Russell R
        • Reynolds F.
        Epidural infusions for nulliparous women in labour: a randomised double-blind comparison of fentanyl/bupivacaine and sufentanil/bupivacaine.
        Anaesthesia. 1993; 48: 856-861
        • Bailey CR
        • Ruggier R
        • Findley IL.
        Diamorphine-bupivacaine mixture compared with plain bupivacaine for analgesia.
        Br J Anaesth. 1994; 72: 58-61
        • Curry PD
        • Pacsoo C
        • Heap DG.
        Patient-controlled epidural analgesia in obstetric anaesthetic practice.
        Pain. 1994; 57: 125-128
        • Abboud TK
        • Swart F
        • Zhu J
        • Donovan MM
        • Da Silva EP
        • Yakal K.
        Desflurane analgesia for vaginal delivery.
        Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 1995; 39: 239-261
        • Peach MJ
        • Pavy TJ
        • Sims C
        • Westmore MD
        • Storey JM
        • White C.
        Clinical experience with patient-controlled and staff-administered intermittent bolus epidural analgesia in labour.
        Anaesth Intensive Care. 1995; 23: 459-463
        • Cohen S
        • Amar D
        • Pantuck CB
        • Pantuck EJ
        • Goodman EJ
        • Leung DH.
        Epidural analgesia for labour and delivery: fentanyl or sufentanil?.
        Can J Anaesth. 1996; 43: 341-346
        • Russell R
        • Reynolds F.
        Epidural infusion of low-dose bupivacaine and opioid in labour: does reducing motor block increase the spontaneous delivery rate?.
        Anaesthesia. 1996; 51: 266-273
        • James KS
        • McGrady E
        • Quasim I
        • Patrick A.
        Comparison of epidural bolus administration of 0.25% bupivacaine and 0.1% bupivacaine with 0.0002% fentanyl for analgesia during labour.
        Br J Anaesth. 1998; 81: 507-510
        • Price C
        • Lafreniere L
        • Brosnan C
        • Findley I.
        Regional analgesia in early active labour: combined spinal epidural vs epidural.
        Anaesthesia. 1998; 58: 951-955
        • Labrecque M
        • Nouwen A
        • Bergeron M
        • Rancourt JF.
        A randomized controlled trial of nonpharmaologic approaches for relief of low back pain during labor.
        J Fam Pract. 1999; 48: 4259-4263
        • Sia AT
        • Chong JL
        • Chiu JW.
        Combination of intrathecal sufentanil 10 plus bupivacaine 2.5 mg for labor analgesia: is half the dose enough?.
        Anesth Analg. 1999; 88: 362-366
        • Fischer C
        • Blanie P
        • Jaouen E
        • Vayssieire C
        • Kaloul I
        • Coltat J-C.
        Ropivacaine, 0.1% plus sufentanil, 0.5% μ/ml, versus bupivacaine, 0.1%, plus sufentanil, 0.5 μ/ml, using patient-controlled epidural analgesia for labor: a double-blind comparison.
        Anesthesiology. 2000; 92: 1588-1593
        • Elbourne D
        • Wiseman RA.
        Types of intra-muscular opioids for maternal pain relief in labour. The Cochrane Library.
        Update Software, Oxford2000 ([software program] Issue 4)
        • Hodnett E
        • Simmons-Tropea D.
        The Labour Agentry Scale: psychometric properties of an instrument measuring control during childbirth.
        Res Nurs Health. 1987; 10: 301-310
        • Lomas J
        • Dore S
        • Enkin M
        • Mitchell A.
        The Labor and Delivery Satisfaction Index: the development and evaluation of a soft outcome measure.
        Birth. 1987; 14: 125-129
        • Lumley J.
        Assessing satisfaction with childbirth.
        Birth. 1985; 12: 141-145
        • Erb L
        • Hill G
        • Houston D.
        A survey of parents' attitudes toward the cesarean births in Manitoba hospitals.
        Birth. 1983; 10: 85-92
        • Bennett A.
        The birth of a first child: do women's reports change over time?.
        Birth. 1985; 12: 153-158
        • Porter M
        • MacIntyre S.
        What is, must be best: a research note on conservative or deferential responses to antenatal care provision.
        Soc Sci Med. 1984; 19: 1197-1200
        • Hodnett E.
        Personal control and the birth environment: comparisons between home and hospital settings.
        J Environ Psychol. 1989; 9: 207-216
        • Simkin P.
        The birth partner.
        Harvard Common Press, Boston2000
        • Melzack R.
        The short-form McGill pain questionnaire.
        Pain. 1987; 30: 191-197